Home › Is a Home Warranty Worth It for a Rental Property?
Is a Home Warranty Worth It for a Rental Property?
The basic math
Say a plan costs $55 a month ($660 a year) and the service fee is $100. In a typical year a rental might need two or three service calls. Compare:
| Year | With a plan | Without a plan |
|---|---|---|
| Quiet year (1 dishwasher repair) | $660 + $100 = $760 | $250 |
| Normal year (water heater + disposal) | $660 + $200 = $860 | $2,400 |
| Bad year (AC compressor + fridge) | $660 + $200 = $860 | $4,800 |
In a quiet year you pay a little more. In a bad year the plan saves thousands, and you know your cost in advance either way.
When it's most worth it
- HVAC or water heater is 10+ years old
- You own the property out of state or don't have a go-to contractor
- You provide appliances (fridge, range, washer, dryer)
- You have little cash reserve per property
When it may not be
- Everything is brand new and still under manufacturer warranty
- You're a handy landlord who does your own repairs
- You have a large reserve fund and an in-house maintenance team
The hidden value: tenant retention
Slow repairs are one of the top reasons tenants move. A turnover costs a month or more of rent plus cleaning and listing costs. Fast, one-call repairs help keep good tenants.
Get a Rental Quote: (844) 786-0283
Frequently asked questions
How many service calls does a rental usually need?
It varies, but older rentals commonly see two to four appliance or system calls a year.
Are older systems covered?
Yes, as long as they're in working order when the plan starts. No inspection is needed.